0004313: php constructor issue

(0004862)
jlangevin
12-01-10 20:04

Just a note, this issue occurred as of 4.0.13, worked fine in 4.0.12

(0004887)
jlangevin
01-04-11 17:40

I assume this issue has not been corrected yet?

(0004892)
domdorn
01-06-11 13:48

Test case:
abstract class Test {
    protected $var;

    public function __construct() {
        $this->var = 'test';
    }
}

class Test2 extends Test {
    public function __construct() {
        parent::__construct();
        $this->var = 'test2';
        var_dump($this->var);
    }
}

$test = new Test2;

works as expected in current trunk. Is this the behavior you described?

(0004893)
jlangevin
01-06-11 14:04

Actually, while that test case basically reflects what appears to be going on, it doesn't actually reproduce the issue.
I ran a similar test case when I reported this issue, and the test functioned fine, so there's an element missing.

The app in question is built on CodeIgniter, and so is likely related to CI somehow...

The app worked fine in Resin 4.0.10-4.0.12, didn't break until 4.0.13, at which point I reverted the server back down to .12.

If there's something further I can do to help reproduce this bug, let me know.

(0004894)
domdorn
01-06-11 14:17

we've worked on issues with ZendFramework in 4.0.12 -> 4.0.13 involving accessors of classes.

If you could track down the issue to a certain code fragment in code igniter (lets say with inserting echo/print statements) so we can create a testcase out of that, that would help a lot!

(0006107)
nam
12-08-12 02:58

Quercus should work with CodeIgniter now. I was able to run a tutorial app and a public app (http://sourceforge.net/projects/hewarforum/) [^] and things look good.

And with respect to the constructor issue, can you send me the code for the classes in question? Thanks.

(0006223)
nam
03-15-13 11:09

Unable to reproduce in 4.0.35.

Issue History
Date Modified	Username	Field	Change
12-01-10 11:18	ferg	New Issue
12-01-10 20:03	jlangevin	Issue Monitored: jlangevin
12-01-10 20:04	jlangevin	Note Added: 0004862
12-02-10 01:48	kdecherf	Issue Monitored: kdecherf
01-04-11 17:40	jlangevin	Note Added: 0004887
01-06-11 13:48	domdorn	Note Added: 0004892
01-06-11 13:48	domdorn	Status	new => feedback
01-06-11 14:04	jlangevin	Note Added: 0004893
01-06-11 14:17	domdorn	Note Added: 0004894
12-08-12 02:58	nam	Note Added: 0006107
03-15-13 11:08	nam	Status	feedback => assigned
03-15-13 11:08	nam	Assigned To	=> nam
03-15-13 11:09	nam	Status	assigned => closed
03-15-13 11:09	nam	Note Added: 0006223
03-15-13 11:09	nam	Resolution	open => unable to reproduce

Notes
(0004862) jlangevin 12-01-10 20:04	Just a note, this issue occurred as of 4.0.13, worked fine in 4.0.12

(0004887) jlangevin 01-04-11 17:40	I assume this issue has not been corrected yet?

(0004892) domdorn 01-06-11 13:48	Test case: abstract class Test { protected $var; public function __construct() { $this->var = 'test'; } } class Test2 extends Test { public function __construct() { parent::__construct(); $this->var = 'test2'; var_dump($this->var); } } $test = new Test2; works as expected in current trunk. Is this the behavior you described?

(0004893) jlangevin 01-06-11 14:04	Actually, while that test case basically reflects what appears to be going on, it doesn't actually reproduce the issue. I ran a similar test case when I reported this issue, and the test functioned fine, so there's an element missing. The app in question is built on CodeIgniter, and so is likely related to CI somehow... The app worked fine in Resin 4.0.10-4.0.12, didn't break until 4.0.13, at which point I reverted the server back down to .12. If there's something further I can do to help reproduce this bug, let me know.

(0004894) domdorn 01-06-11 14:17	we've worked on issues with ZendFramework in 4.0.12 -> 4.0.13 involving accessors of classes. If you could track down the issue to a certain code fragment in code igniter (lets say with inserting echo/print statements) so we can create a testcase out of that, that would help a lot!

(0006107) nam 12-08-12 02:58	Quercus should work with CodeIgniter now. I was able to run a tutorial app and a public app (http://sourceforge.net/projects/hewarforum/) [^] and things look good. And with respect to the constructor issue, can you send me the code for the classes in question? Thanks.

(0006223) nam 03-15-13 11:09	Unable to reproduce in 4.0.35.

Relationships