Mantis Bugtracker

Viewing Issue Simple Details Jump to Notes ] View Advanced ] Issue History ] Print ]
ID Category Severity Reproducibility Date Submitted Last Update
0003764 [Quercus] minor always 11-16-09 12:07 12-01-22 18:01
Reporter dobes_vandermeer View Status public  
Assigned To
Priority normal Resolution open  
Status new   Product Version
Summary 0003764: fread() on a regular file doesn't return all requested bytes?
Description I recently encountered an issue where calls to fread() on a regular file returned fewer bytes than requested. This causes issues in code which relies on the PHP core implementation's behavior where fread() and fwrite always write completely for regular files, despite the documentation saying that it may read or write fewer bytes.

I submitted an issue with WordPress [^] about their false assumptions around fread() but I think it would make easier to run existing apps on Quercus if it showed the same behavior as the core PHP app rather than making everyone else fix their PHP code.
Additional Information
Attached Files

- Relationships

- Notes
Chris Graham
05-23-10 06:10

The PHP manual is (at least now) quite specific about when full data won't be returned:
1) EOF (end of file) is reached
2) a packet becomes available (for network streams)
3) 8192 bytes have been read (after opening userspace stream)

None of these are your pedestrian scenarios of fread use, so I believe we have a bug in Quercus and not people's code. I think that's reasonable too, people shouldn't have to worry about issues like this for such a basic function.

I think it is the same as issues 0003894 and 0003765. I examined the Wordpress code referenced here and it was indeed loading large amounts of data, presumably over that 8kb bug-inducing threshold.

The good news is people worried about this bug only need to think of scenarios where they are reading more than 8kb.
07-20-10 10:47

This Behavior make Wordpress 3.0 in French unusable because Wordpress is unable to load the translation file The fread funtion read only 8164 bytes but the file is much larger.
jendy henna
12-01-22 18:01
edited on: 12-01-22 18:02

This essay is critical, but it also [^] instructs us on how to live morally and kindly; rather than acting selfishly, we should live to give and then receive respect.


- Issue History
Date Modified Username Field Change
11-16-09 12:07 dobes_vandermeer New Issue
05-22-10 04:19 Chris Graham Issue Monitored: Chris Graham
05-23-10 06:10 Chris Graham Note Added: 0004608
07-20-10 10:43 dunand Issue Monitored: dunand
07-20-10 10:47 dunand Note Added: 0004677
12-01-22 18:01 jendy henna Note Added: 0007137
12-01-22 18:02 jendy henna Note Edited: 0007137
12-01-22 18:02 jendy henna Note Edited: 0007137

Mantis 1.0.0rc3[^]
Copyright © 2000 - 2005 Mantis Group
41 total queries executed.
32 unique queries executed.
Powered by Mantis Bugtracker